The Mets' 2023 draft was a strategic move that showcased their ability to identify and develop talent. While some picks have fallen short of expectations, others have proven to be impactful contributors to the team's success. One standout player is Nolan McLean, a two-way player who has quickly risen through the ranks. Despite initially struggling with hitting, McLean's pitching prowess caught the Mets' attention, and he has since become a potential frontline starter with a 3.20 ERA and 1.10 WHIP across 143.1 innings. This highlights the team's foresight in recognizing and nurturing his two-way abilities.
A.J. Ewing, drafted in the fourth round, has also made a significant impact. Initially a shortstop, Ewing's versatility and defensive skills led to his conversion to the outfield, where he has thrived. His swing change in the minors has contributed to his power and speed, as evidenced by his .275/.360/.412/.772 slash line. Ewing's ability to adapt and improve makes him a valuable asset, capable of providing both offensive and defensive contributions.
The Mets' decision to draft Brandon Sproat twice showcases their commitment to his potential. However, Sproat's struggles in 2025 led to a pitch mix change, aiming to suppress contact. While his results have been mixed, there is optimism that he can improve. The trade involving Sproat brought in Freddy Peralta and Tobias Myers, indicating the team's willingness to make strategic moves to strengthen their roster.
Colin Houck, taken in the first round, has faced challenges. His struggles in High-A and the comparison to Kevin McGonigle, a rumored target, highlight the risks associated with early-round picks. Houck's performance has been underwhelming, with a .105/.270/.315/.585 slash line, making it difficult to envision a path to the majors. This serves as a reminder that draft success is not guaranteed and can be influenced by various factors.
Zach Thornton, a fifth-round pick, has shown promise as a pitcher. His recent outing against the Phillies, where he pitched six innings of one-run ball, demonstrates his ability to make strategic pitch mix changes. Thornton's potential as a backend starter or swing man is evident, but his velocity needs improvement to reach his full potential.
Jack Wennigner, a sixth-round pick, has received top 100 list buzz despite a slight dip in June. His struggles with velocity maintenance may lead to a role as a back-end reliever, but this is a positive outcome for a sixth-round selection. The team's ability to identify and develop players with potential is a testament to their scouting and development prowess.
Ben Simon, a 13th-round pick, has excelled in Double-A and Triple-A, showcasing multiple plus pitches and a 2.35 ERA and 1.14 WHIP. His performance has earned him a strong case for a major league roster spot. The Mets' investment in players like Simon demonstrates their commitment to long-term success and the development of young talent.
The trade involving Kade Morris, a third-round pick, highlights the team's willingness to make strategic moves. Morris' mixed results in Triple-A and the minors, with a 4.41 ERA and 1.38 WHIP, serve as a reminder that not all draft picks will pan out as expected. The Mets' ability to adapt and make informed decisions is crucial to their overall success.
